George B

always an A+ for a true New Yorker like myself

Sarah F

My partner and I split two delicious bagels– one special with lox, cream cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, and avocado on an onion bagel, and another whitefish salad sandwich with lettuce and tomato on an everything bagel. I would highly recommend this place for anyone looking to get their NY bagel fix!

Paulien S

This is the best bagel store in Brooklyn. Love the cream cheeses, especially guacamole cream cheese.

Daniel K

Fantastic bagels. It’s that simple. Fresh, crisp, yet soft inside. Get em fresh. Good coffee as well. Can’t go wrong here.

Darcy G

The best place for a new York bagel!!!!!!!

Laura S

The cream cheese and tofu cream cheese selection is phenomenal.

Elizabeth E

I have been going to Smith St. Bagels for years and absolutely love the fresh bagels, atmosphere, and friendly staff.

Birgit K

If yelp would have seven stars I would give Smith St Bagels all of them.

Nicole B

Best bagels in Brooklyn! I love this place, been enjoying their bagels every Sunday morning for 7 years.

Steph C

This place is head and shoulders above the sad excuse for a bagel cafe down by the Carroll Street station.


Share a Bagel

Buy Gift Card